Around 1870 Pierre Cuypers proposed a church on land he controlled, which gave him freedom to shape both the building and its setting. He placed it on an oval island in line with the Vondelstraat, which was split to run round it on both sides: the first free-standing church in Amsterdam since the Middle Ages. The foundation stone was laid in 1872. When money ran out after the choir was finished, a national lottery in 1875 raised 45,000 guilders; Queen Sophie gave two salon lamps and Pope Pius IX a cameo as prizes. The church of the Sacred Heart opened in 1880.
On 8 November 1904 a plumber's fire pot set the 50-metre wooden tower alight, and tower and roof collapsed. Jos Cuypers rebuilt the tower slightly lower. The church closed in 1978, was sold for one guilder, squatted, saved by a foundation and reopened as a cultural venue in 1986. On New Year's night 2026 fire broke out again, and parts of the building, including the main tower, collapsed.
The parsonage of 1882 stands just north of the church, set back from the street.
Look for:
- the octagonal crossing tower at the heart of the centralised plan
- the fence round the church, placed in 1884
- the parsonage's balcony running the full width of the front on five heavy stone brackets, a rare feature