The church does not stand on the Nieuwendammerdijk but a little below it, at the end of the Brede Kerkepad (broad church path), surrounded by its graveyard. Nieuwendam got its own congregation in 1635, and in 1643 a plot was donated to build a church and lay out a burial ground. That first church of 1644 had become unsafe by 1847 and was pulled down; the present hall church was built in 1848–1849 for the Reformed congregation, opening on 18 February 1849. The village council paid 3,000 guilders towards the tower. The initials on the foundation stone are those of the minister's son, who laid it.
It is a sober eclectic building in yellow IJssel brick and red brick, with a square tower carrying a slate-covered octagonal spire and a wrought-iron finial. Inside, the roof rests on timber trusses related to the English hammerbeam type. The tombstones in the floor came from the old church, as did the 17th-century oak pulpit, carved with figures of the virtues, and the bell in the tower, cast in Kampen in 1644. The two-manual organ was made in 1849 by J. Hoffmeijer, his only church organ, and was restored to its original state in 2009–2010. A stone inside marks how high the water rose in the flood of 1916. The church is still in use, and the city restored the tower in 2022–2023.
Look for:
- the stone with the initials by the entrance
- the iron railing on a brick base around the churchyard
- old gravestones in the churchyard
- the four clock faces in the narrow upper stage of the tower